Active recall: how to turn your notes into questions
How active recall works, why it beats rereading, and a step-by-step way to turn any page of your notes into questions you can test yourself with.
Active recall means pulling an answer out of your memory before you look at it, instead of reading it again. It is one of the best-supported study methods there is: in study after study, people who test themselves remember more a week later than people who spend the same time rereading. The practical problem is that most notes aren't written as questions, so there is nothing to test yourself with. This article explains why active recall works and gives you a step-by-step way to turn any page of notes into questions, plus the mistakes that make self-testing less useful than it should be.
The answer in brief
- Active recall (also called retrieval practice) is answering from memory first, then checking.
- Testing yourself beats rereading for long-term memory, even when rereading takes more time.
- Turn each important note into a question with a clear answer, and keep the answer out of sight.
- Recall first, out loud or in writing, then check and mark what you missed.
- Repeat at growing gaps: active recall and spaced repetition work best together.
What is active recall?
Active recall is any study activity where you produce the answer instead of recognising it. Covering your notes and saying what's under them is active recall. So is answering a practice question, explaining a topic to someone without notes, or writing everything you remember about a lecture on a blank page.
Rereading, highlighting and watching a lecture again are the opposite: passive review. The information is in front of you, so you recognise it, and recognising feels like knowing.
In research, the benefit of recall is called the testing effect or retrieval practice. The word "test" puts people off, but these tests don't need marks or a teacher. A question you ask yourself counts.
Why does active recall work better than rereading?
The classic experiment
In a 2006 study, Roediger and Karpicke had students study short prose passages. Some kept restudying; others studied once and then took recall tests. On a test 5 minutes later, the restudy group did slightly better. On tests 2 days and a week later, the pattern reversed. According to Washington University's summary, after a week the repeated-test group remembered 61% of the passage against 40% for the study-only group, even though the study-only group had read the passage about 14 times and the test group about 3 or 4.
That last detail matters. Recall didn't win by giving people more time with the material. It won with less.
It beats more elaborate methods too
A study by Karpicke and Blunt (2011) compared retrieval practice with building concept maps, a demanding method that many teachers recommend. A week later, students who had practised recall did better, including on questions that asked them to draw inferences, not only to repeat facts. The students' own predictions didn't match the results: their expectations of what would work best were off.
Reviews of study methods agree
The 2013 review by Dunlosky and colleagues looked at ten common techniques and gave its highest rating to two: practice testing and spaced practice. Rereading, highlighting and summarising got low ratings.
Most students do the opposite
In a survey of 177 college students, Karpicke, Butler and Roediger (2009) found that rereading was by far the most common strategy, and only a small minority described testing themselves. Education Week's report on this line of work puts it at 84% who reread and 11% who regularly quiz themselves.
Why rereading feels better than it is
When you reread notes, the words are familiar, and familiarity feels like understanding. But a test asks you to produce the answer with nothing in front of you, which is a different skill. Recall practises that skill directly. It also shows you what you don't know, which rereading hides. This is one of the "desirable difficulties" described by Elizabeth and Robert Bjork: it feels harder, and that effort is what makes memory last.
How to turn your notes into questions
Most notes are statements: "TCP guarantees delivery; UDP does not." To practise recall, you need a question that the statement answers. Here is the procedure.
Pick one session's notes, such as one lecture or one chapter. Don't try to convert a whole course at once.
Find the ideas that matter. Skip page references, examples you won't need and anything you can look up in seconds. Underline or mark the 5 to 15 ideas you would be annoyed to forget.
For each idea, ask what question it answers. Write the question above or beside the note. Use the question types in the table below.
Make each question answerable in a sentence or two. If the answer is a paragraph, split it into two or three questions.
Write the answer in your own words, under the question or on the back of a card. Copying the textbook's sentence word for word makes it harder to tell whether you understood it.
Hide the answers. Fold the page, use a two-column layout and cover one side, or put the questions on cards.
Test yourself straight away, once. Answer every question from memory, then check. This catches badly written questions while the material is fresh.
Mark what you missed and bring those questions back first next time.
Question types that work
Different kinds of notes call for different kinds of question. A mix of these gives you better practice than a list of "what is" questions.
| Note looks like | Question type | Example |
|---|---|---|
| A definition | What is it? | What does a p-value measure? |
| A cause or reason | Why? | Why do sample means look normal even when the data isn't? |
| A process | How does it work, step by step? | What happens when my program asks for a web page? |
| Two similar ideas | What is the difference? | How is a tuple different from a list? |
| A rule or principle | When does it apply, and when not? | When can't I use binary search? |
| A worked example | Can I do one like it? | Find the median of 3, 9, 4, 7 and 12. |
| A key idea from a lecture | Explain it to a beginner | Explain what a pointer stores, in two sentences. |
A worked example: notes before and after
Here are notes from a lesson on Python dictionaries, as many people write them:
- Dictionaries store key-value pairs.
- Keys must be unique and unchangeable (strings, numbers, tuples).
- Look up a value with its key; a missing key raises an error unless you use get.
- Good for counting things.
And here are the same notes as questions, each with its answer kept out of sight:
- What does a dictionary store, and how do you get a value out of it?
- Which kinds of value can be a dictionary key, and why can't a list be one?
- What happens if you look up a key that isn't there, and how do you avoid an error?
- How would you count how often each word appears in a line of text, using a dictionary?
The second version takes about five minutes longer to write. In return, every line is now something you can be tested on. The last question goes further than the notes did: it asks you to use the idea, not only to describe it. When you answer it from memory a few days later, you will find out whether you understood dictionaries or only recognised the word.
Write good questions, not trick questions
- One idea per question. "What are the four domains of the exam and their weights?" is four questions, not one.
- Ask for meaning, not wording. "Why does C need types?" is better than "Fill in the blank: C is a ____ language."
- Keep the question specific enough to have one right answer. "Tell me about memory" can't be graded.
- Add context if it helps you recall the right thing. "In SQL, how do I join two tables to answer one question?"
Other ways to practise active recall
Questions on cards are the most flexible format, but they aren't the only one.
- The blank page. After a lecture or chapter, write down everything you remember, with no notes. Then compare with your notes and fill the gaps in a different colour. It is good for seeing the structure of a topic.
- Explain it out loud. Pretend you are teaching the topic to someone who missed the class. Where you stall, you have found a gap. The BCIT library's guide to active recall lists this alongside self-quizzing and practice problems.
- Practice problems. In maths, programming and the sciences, solving a new problem is recall: you have to bring back the method, not recognise it.
- Past papers and practice exams. These are recall at the scale of a whole course, and also show you how questions are asked.
- Cover the answer column. If your notes are in two columns (questions on the left, notes on the right), cover the right side and answer from the left. This is the recite step of the Cornell method; see Cornell notes, on paper and on screen.
How to check your answers
Recall only helps if you check, and check honestly.
Commit before you look. Say the answer out loud or type it. A half-formed thought you "basically had" isn't an answer.
Compare with the real answer, not with your memory of it.
Grade it in one of three ways: right, partly right, or wrong.
For partly right and wrong answers, write one line on what you missed. "Mixed up independent and mutually exclusive" tells you what to fix.
Bring the misses back soonest. A wrong answer you correct and then recall correctly a day later is one of the strongest learning events you can have.
How active recall fits with spacing
Active recall and spacing are separate ideas, and they work best together. Recall decides how you review (answer first, then check). Spacing decides when you review (at growing gaps). A question you recall once and never see again fades; a question you recall at 1 day, 3 days and a week later lasts. For a schedule you can follow, see spaced repetition: a simple review schedule.
| Method | Recall? | Spaced? | What it builds |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rereading notes the night before | No | No | Familiarity, short-lived |
| Rereading notes every few days | No | Yes | Familiarity that lasts longer |
| A practice test the night before | Yes | No | Recall, short-lived |
| Self-testing at growing gaps | Yes | Yes | Recall that lasts |
Doing it in Soundings
Soundings is built so that your notes are questions from the start. In a session, start a line with q: to write a question at its moment in the video, page or live class, and with a: to answer it when you find the answer (Write notes, questions and answers). Every answered question becomes a recall card for Review, with no separate deck to build (How recall cards work). In a PDF or a transcript, select words and choose Card to write the question those words answer.
To practise without changing your review schedule, Quiz yourself on the Questions board asks your own questions in a shuffled order, and recall mode on a topic's page covers every answer until you choose to show it (Quiz yourself and use recall mode). If you want to commit before you look, turn on Type my answer before it shows in Settings and data, Study habits, and Review gives you a box to type your answer before it shows the real one.
Common questions
Is active recall the same as flashcards?
Flashcards are one way to do active recall. The method is producing the answer from memory before you check; cards, practice problems, a blank page and explaining aloud all do that. Flashcards are popular because they are quick to review and fit a spacing schedule.
How many questions should I write per lecture?
Enough to cover the ideas you would not want to forget, usually somewhere between 5 and 20 for an hour of material. More questions isn't better if they are trivial. Write the question you would expect on a good exam.
What if I can't answer any of my questions?
That is useful information, not failure. Look at the answer, then try to recall it again in a few minutes and again the next day. If a whole topic is blank, go back to the source material first, then return to recall.
Is it better to recall out loud or in writing?
Both work. Writing makes it harder to fool yourself, because you can compare your words with the answer. Saying it out loud is faster for review. Whichever you choose, commit to an answer before you look.
Should I still reread my notes?
Rereading helps you understand material the first time and find what to turn into questions. After that, your time is better spent on recall. A good rule is to read once to understand, then test yourself instead of reading again.
Does active recall work for subjects like maths or programming?
Yes. In these subjects, recall usually looks like solving a new problem or writing code from a blank file rather than reciting facts. Ask yourself questions about why a method works and when to use it, as well as practising the method itself.